First & Last Name: Period:

Cinderella Story Comparison Graphic Organizer

What lessons or morals are demonstrated in this version of Cinderella? Share at least two.

What does this culture value? (What are the beliefs of this culture?)

Share at least two.

What might be some symbols in this story? AND What could they represent? Share at least two. Taking a deeper dive: Research credible sources and find out if the culture in this region/area THEN AND/OR NOW has the same lessons/morals, values/beliefs, and/or symbols/representations. Share if they are the same or how they are now different. Site source (can paste the URL) - Take your time and look at multiple sources. Look at .edu sites, .gov sites - tourism sites or historical sites. Use Google Advanced Search to help you.

Version #1

“Yeh Shen”

Chinese Cinderella Story

  • Whatever comes around goes around

  • Don’t judge a book by its cover

  • Inner beauty matches outer beauty

  • Multiple wives

  • Animals or animals with spirits

  • Values old people and their wisdom

  • Fish bones : Fairy godmother

  • Dagger : Death

  • Tears in the pond : Love

  • Golden shoe

  • Old Man : Wisdom

  • During the tang dynasty

  • Patriarchy

  • Women beauty standards

  • Men were above women

  • China respects others for thousands of years

https://carnegieendowment.org/2013/11/21/china-s-traditional-cultural-values-and-national-identity-pub-53613

Version #2

“The Golden Sandal”

A Middle Eastern Cinderella Story

  • Don’t judge a book by

its cover

  • Treat others how you want to be treated

  • Karma

  • Kindness goes a long way

  • King marries one woman

  • Weddings/Henna

  • Woman stays home

  • Belief in a god

  • Mother is valued and gives blessing

  • Fine clothing

  • Red Fish : Fairy godmother

  • Perfume : Karma

  • Fine Clothing : Her dress

  • Rooster : Maha’s savior

  • Golden Sandals : Purity

  • Men worked/ruled kingdoms - Patriarchy

  • Middle East - Arab / Muslim Culture

  • Massive culture (land and philosophical wise)

  • Woman are valued more than other cultures and civilizations

  • Represent family and culture

https://www.osti.gov/biblio/5537055

Version #3:

“Mufaro’s Beautiful Daughters”

African Cinderella Story

  • Treat others how you want to be treated

  • Stay close to earth/be humble

  • Don’t envy others

  • Don’t be selfish

  • What comes around goes around

  • Wedding party

  • Wedding Feast

  • Family and relationships

  • Sunflower seeds/Yams : Kindness

  • Mysterious Woman/Spirit : Karma

  • King/Crossing river : Test of purity

  • Fine clothing : Dress

  • First light of dawn : New day/Change

  • African Folktale

  • 5 points -> crown

  • Textiles can be forms of communication

  • Belief in spirits and traditions

  • Different art, traditions, and religions

  • No person is more beautiful or ugly

https://journals.co.za/doi/epdf/10.10520/EJC189182

Version #4

“Rough Faced Girl”

American Indigenous Story

  • Be truthful to yourself

  • Don't be selfish or envious of others.

  • Don't judge a book by its cover

  • Lying gets you nowhere

  • Marriage

  • Truthfulness

  • Nature

  • Clothing of animal skins

  • People of truth/kind heart

  • Beauty and appreciation of nature

  • Wigwam : Divinity or knowledge

  • Fire and scars :

  • Invisible man’s bow : Truth

  • Moccasins, broken shells, buckskin: Family

  • Stars : Truth or Wisdom

  • Invisible man : Purity

  • Worship and value nature and purity

  • Theres a lot of diversity between tribes including traditions and stories

  • Many different stories between tribes

  • Trying to keep beliefs and traditions alive today due to cultural decline

https://www.proquest.com/docview/2589646780/868CEEA2DE404EE6PQ/3?accountid=134741

Version #5

Story Name Here

  • Love and respect everyone

  • Don’t judge a book by its cover

  • Don't be jealous or envious of others success

  • Hardships of families and work

  • Love for family

  • Respect for others

  • Nopales : Love

  • Malvina : Deception or lies

  • Manton : Family heritage or caring

  • Mama : Purity or respect for others.

  • Mud Bricks : Hardships of life

  • Food is integral to Mexican culture

  • Family is important and you should love and care for them

  • Mexican culture really focuses on tradition and love especially for each other and taking care of others. Doing things out of the goodwill of your heart.

https://www.donquijote.org/mexican-culture/